Request A Demo
What Are the Pros and Cons of Black Friday and Cyber Monday for Retailers?

What Are the Pros and Cons of Black Friday and Cyber Monday for Retailers?


Twitter Share Link Facebook Share Link Linkedin Share Link

Using opinions from a SaleCycle survey of US and UK retailers, we look at some of the pros and cons of participating in discounting around Black Friday weekend.

The majority of retailers will be taking part in Black Friday promotions this year, according to our survey of retailers.

However, retailers have differing views around Black Friday, so we asked our survey respondents for the pros and cons as they see them.

Black Friday Pros

Increased Traffic and Sales

People are looking for deals, they’re also shopping for Christmas, and Black Friday and Cyber Monday focuses a lot of traffic and sales into a short period.

Last year, we saw sales volumes many times those of an average day on both Black Friday and Cyber Monday.

This is a clear opportunity for retailers to capitalize on customer demand and bring extra traffic to their sites.

An Opportunity to Clear Stock Before Christmas Season

Many retailers see Black Friday as an opportunity to clear old inventory in order to introduce newer stock in time for Christmas.

This applies to fashion retailers of course, but electronics retailers can also offer discounts on items like TVs and laptops knowing that newer models are coming soon.

Customer Acquisition

New customer acquisition can be expensive, but Black Friday offers retailers a chance to acquire new customers at a key time of year.

If you acquire customers around Black Friday, and keep them happy, then you have a chance to drive repeat sales in the Christmas period and beyond.

If customers can be retained in the longer term and they buy at full price later, this justifies discounting around Black Friday.

Incremental Sales

People have a real intent to purchase around the Black Friday weekend and this can translate into incremental sales.

This means that customers head to sites looking for bargains, but end up buying full-price items as the money is burning a hole in their pockets.

Our own stats from last year show this propensity to buy. Normally, abandonment rates for retailers are around 84%, but they’re much lower around Black Friday weekend.

Last year, abandonment rates dropped to 80.9% on Black Friday and 82.8% on Cyber Monday as people looked to grab a bargain.

Black Friday abandonment rates

Pro:Direct Sport Digital Marketing Manager David Tapp has seen this in action:

“Black Friday is a great day for driving users into the site for sale items, but it’s also a huge day for non-sale items too, with users coming to see if that item they wanted has been discounted, and then buying it even if it isn’t”

Easier Fulfilment

One benefit of shifting sales to earlier in the Christmas shopping season is that orders can be processed and shipped well before Christmas.

This means there’s no danger that people won’t receive gifts in time for Christmas, and also frees up capacity for later in the season.

Black Friday Cons

Pressure to Discount

Black Friday has been known for generous discounts, and some customers have come to expect it.

This places pressure on retailers, as Simon Lancaster, Senior Optimisation and Analytics Manager at Tesco Mobile explains:

“Customers expect expect very heavy discounting. Which most mobile operators can’t do – particularly on Apple handsets where margins are smaller anyway.”

Impact on Margins

Our survey respondents were concerned about the impact on margins around Black Friday.

More sales are generated around Black Friday, and many retailers enjoy their busiest sales days of the year, but it can come at the cost of reduced profit margins.

Nike’s Gabriela Bergamasco explains the challenge for brands:

“As the consumer is already expecting offers, we can not avoid it (Black Friday). If we want a share of their spending, we must get attract customers’ attention with offers. However, we must be careful with our product margin to guarantee final results.”

Retailers need to consider how far they can realistically discount, as they can reduce margins on products they may have sold closer to Christmas at full price.

Then again, if they don’t discount, but their competitors do, retailers may be losing out to competitors.

It’s a conundrum for retailers.

It Can Generate Returns

Discounting and therefore selling more at this stage of the holiday season means that some goods will be returned in the final weeks running up to Christmas.

That means that retailers’ distribution centres can become even busier at their busiest time of year.

There’s also a risk that goods returned may not be able to be sold before Christmas and may sit on the shelves until the next gift period comes along.

It’s Crowded and Competitive

With so many brands talking about their Black Friday discounts, it can be hard for a retailer to have their message heard above the noise.

Also, while Black Friday drives more search traffic, it also increases the competition for retailers.

Terms like ‘Black Friday deals’ are now targeted by publishers looking to push up traffic numbers, which makes it harder for retailers to achieve higher search positions for such terms.

Customers Have Been Trained to Wait for the Discount

With Black Friday / Cyber Monday now firmly established in customers’ minds, people are now expecting discounts.

This has a couple of effects. Firstly, sales are likely to drop in the weeks leading up to Black Friday, as customers prefer to wait for the possibility of a discount rather than buying items at full price.

Secondly, if shoppers expect mega discounts, it’s harder to persuade them to buy, even with a good discount.

With the nagging thought that better discounts might be out there, customers may be more likely to shop around before committing to a purchase.
This presents a challenge for retailers. They could look to price match as Curry’s does here (cleverly targeting customers who copy product titles) or stick to their guns and risk losing sales to competitors.

In Summary

Black Friday and Cyber Monday present many challenges for retailers, and they have to consider some of the cons of participating.

However, there are many positives to this retail event and, if managed well, retailers can look after their margins while managing to generate extra sales and acquire new customers.

Want to talk about cart abandonment?

Just enter your email below and let’s talk about how you can help build trust and increase conversions.


The 2021 Ecommerce Stats & Trends Report

The latest data on ecommerce trends and online customer behaviour

2021 Ecommerce Stats & Trends Report

Graham Charlton

Graham Charlton is Editor in Chief at SaleCycle. He's been covering ecommerce and digital marketing for more than a decade, having previously written reports and articles for Econsultancy. ClickZ, Search Engine Watch and more.